RE: Subfile question -- RPG400-L

Hi Don,

<snip>
I've wondered about that many times over the years.  Paul's assertion that
setting SFLSIZ and SFLPAG to be identical will make it work makes me wonder
what is special about that condition.  If it works for one subfile page, why
not more?  
</snip>

I believe the point of a "field selection subfile" is to mimic a panel. I
have written several such subfiles to run in our applications, but I've
never used one in a way that allows you to page-up or page-down. They have
always been used for field selection panels. That's why pageup and pagedown
are disabled. That's also why you specify that your complete subfile will
fit on a single page - it's a panel.

Think of this scenario: We have a generic screen that is used to allow users
to enter selection criteria for submission of various reports. The same
screen is used for ALL of our reports. Consequently, there are MANY fields
that the user can possibly input data into. Now, most of these fields are
optional. That is, they will be displayed for some reports but not for
others. Logically you condition these fields on indicators and display the
ones you need for a particular report.

The two big problems with this are:

1) You quickly run out of space to fit fields in your panel.
2) As most reports will use only some of these fields, you end up with big
"holes" in your entry screen.

This is very annoying, especially if you have a report that only takes four
values and they're spread all over the screen because that was the only
space left in an already cluttered panel. 

The answer??? Use a field selection subfile. This allows you to build your
panel dynamically. As all fields are added as you write your subfile lines,
you don't have any gaps in your screen. It builds from the top down. When
our report selection app is run, the fields are retrieved from a file and
the selection screen is "custom built" for that report. If we add a new
field to filter on the report, it's added to the file and it appears on the
screen!

So, it's a myth that you can't generate a subfile with each line having
different fields to the other lines. It's actually quite easy. The only
downside is that you have to handle a lot more when processing the records
in the subfile - you need to know which of the possible n fields on your
current record is actually enabled. If you use paging you have to rebuild
your subfile from scratch each time - it can only fit on one page after all.
This is usually done using arrays and "windowing" your subfile up and down
the array.

I must say that we use these "panels" more and more. Once you've written one
you will never look back! They look so clean, and every selection panel has
a similar look-and-feel to every other related selection panel - usually
because most of the time they are actually the same panel!

Give it a go.

Cheers

Larry