Re: Upgrade Question

[PaulMmn <PaulMmn@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Steve--

I'd recommend using option 1 or 2.  Loading the existing OS and 
programs, you're "guaranteed" that it will work OK-- because you're 
not changing anything (except the hardware).

Unless you upgrade the OS at some point, you'll have to do without OS 
support.  Make sure your management understands that support will go 
away, and make sure you get their decision in writing!!

I think that upgrading the OS in the new LPAR is the best choice.

Option 3, loading 7.4 and then loading all of the existing programs 
&c on top of the new OS, is (IMHO) asking for trouble!  Read the 7.3 
and 7.4 Letters to Users-- I'm sure there are a lot of changes that 
will affect you-- even if you think you have all the bases covered!

I hope you have enough space to create a nice test LPAR--  You can 
try it both ways!  And keep the best one.

--Paul E Musselman

.




At 5:24 PM -0500 10/1/20, Steve M via MIDRANGE-L wrote:
> We are preparing to setup a new LPAR and I have an on-going battle with
> management (surprise, eh?).
>
> Three options:
> 1.  Load the new LPAR with 7.2 (our current O/S) and not worry about it
> being no longer supported after 4/30/21.
> 2.  Load the new LPAR with 7.2, then later, do an upgrade to 7.4.
> 3.  Load the new LPAR with 7.4 (and then load the backup created from the
> 7.2 system).
>
> Obviously the first one is stupid, but at the moment their one of choice.
> The third one is the right choice, but they don't want to have to do
> regression testing after loading to make sure everything works on the new
> LPAR.  The middle one gives them a new LPAR that will run immediately, but
> later bite-the-bullet on upgrading and ensuring all the applications still
> work.
>
> Here are my questions.
> 1.  Those who have made the 7.2 to 7.4 jump, after all of the vendors say we
> have compliant software installed, have you had any issues?  If so, what
> kind of pitfalls would be ahead?
> 2.  What was your system outage time when upgrading from 7.2 to 7.4?  I am
> trying to use this to leverage the third option that they'll have a future
> extended outage if they take option 2.
> 3.  Any other issues anyone encountered during either a clean 7.4 load from
> 7.2 backup or during a 7.2 to 7.4 upgrade?
>
> I would have thought that all of the enhancements (both security and coding)
> and the loss of support would have been convincing enough but, alas, I have
> yet to succeed in selling them on option 3.
>
> As always, thanks to all for taking the time to share your experiences.
>
> Steve Meisinger