Re: qsh from cl

Hi John

I might have been a bit loose and conversational with the expression "a
whole pile". And the ambiguity comment. :)

I rarely go more than 1 or 2 parameters on the command line without
specifying the option as well and pretty much always specify the options in
CL.
In fact, I will sometimes go so far as to include options I want to be
certain of so they are visible in the program (and in case someone decides
to change a default which has happened to me at least once)

You misunderstood the prettifier suggestion (which was a little bit tongue
in cheek) I just meant writing something to clean up and prettify your CL
code which would not be so hard. Keyword followed by space (it's a command)
keyword followed by bracket (it's an option so indent/newline) etc. allow
for IF, DO, etc and you're just about there.

For what it's worth I think CL verbose as it is is fine the way it is. It
is not intended to be a programming language for writing applications, so
it doesn't the elegance of some other languages. I get that you find it
ugly but I think the alternative - for example cryptic, confusing
inconsistent unix command lines - is worth the small amount of visual pain.

CL is kind of intended for operators not programmers as I see it, so the
design makes sense from that perspective.

I don't think it's any accident that PowerShell reminds me quite a bit of
CL.


On Wed, Mar 7, 2018 at 10:57 AM, John Yeung <gallium.arsenide@xxxxxxxxx>
wrote:

On Tue, Mar 6, 2018 at 3:44 PM, Evan Harris <auctionitis@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:

Personally I think the idea of a whole pile of parameters with no

keywords

would be even uglier than the verbose string the CL prompter produces.

IBM-supplied commands don't let you have "a whole pile" of parameters
with no keywords. Usually just two or three. But the whole point is
that those parameters are the ones that are (generally speaking)
needed the most, and are the most obvious.

Command design is an art, and there certainly is such a thing as too
many positional parameters.

Despite the perceived ugliness including the keywords removes pretty much
all the possible ambiguity.

Not just pretty much. It removes exactly all the ambiguity. That is
why it is, as a pure matter of objective fact, the safest option.

If I was that horrified I think I would write a CL "prettifier" in

Python,

but I've been looking at CL so long I find the prompts comforting.

Don't think I haven't imagined doing that. But I don't think it's
worth the investment of time. The balance of "data" versus "algorithm"
is tilted heavily toward data, because the prettifier would have to
know which keywords can be left out. You would have to essentially
build a database of prettifiable commands and their parameters. Which,
if you want to prettify a lot of commands, would probably be more
tedious than fun. The indenter portion of the prettifier would be more
algorithm-oriented, though, so that could be fun.

Actually, prompted CL code feels to me kind of like "generated code"
more than it feels like code written by humans, for humans. (After
all, it *is* kind of generated, though just one line at a time.) As
such, it would totally make sense to create some other language which
is aesthetically nice but "transpiles" to CL (in a similar way that
CoffeeScript and TypeScript transpile to JavaScript). That's more
effort but also probably more fun and potentially more useful than a
prettifier. With CL's increasing capabilities, it becomes an
increasingly attractive target for transpilation.

John Y.
--
This is the Midrange Systems Technical Discussion (MIDRANGE-L) mailing list
To post a message email: MIDRANGE-L@xxxxxxxxxxxx
To subscribe, unsubscribe, or change list options,
visit: https://lists.midrange.com/mailman/listinfo/midrange-l
or email: MIDRANGE-L-request@xxxxxxxxxxxx
Before posting, please take a moment to review the archives
at https://archive.midrange.com/midrange-l.

Please contact support@xxxxxxxxxxxx for any subscription related
questions.

Help support midrange.com by shopping at amazon.com with our affiliate
link: http://amzn.to/2dEadiD