[WDSCI-L] RSE LPEX CL editor problems

[Vern Hamberg <vhamberg@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

I have an open PMR about problems with the WDSC RSE CL editor. I like the 
new formatting controls, but there are some irritations and a couple real 
gotchas. Here's what I've found, for all your consideration. See whether 
you get the same results, and, if so, submit a defect report with your 
examples. Somehow the function of the parser of SEU is not getting 
duplicated properly. Someone, please look at THAT code again and see how 
things are done correctly. I mean, this is 20+ year-old code - it works!

I believe I was told when I'd submitted a similar report, that the prompter 
is from some source other than the WDSC team and is not under their control 
- or something, unlike the CODE prompter. All I have to say is, this 
dependency on, I believe, open source is not sufficient here.

I've not tried these things in CODE - I leave that as an exercise for those 
who have no life.

================================================
1. Commands that have no parameters (ENDPGM, e.g.) cannot be prompted.

2. The prompter says that the following needs a variable name in the VAR 
parameter:

CHGVAR VAR(%BIN(&RCVRLEN)) VALUE(60)

This command is completely valid - the prompter needs to handle valid 
expressions in cases such as this.

3. Comments and labels are not displayed in the prompt, as they are in SEU. 
The promise of WDSC is to do better than SEU - this is lost functionality.

4. In a prompt in SEU, if I type any character of a default value, it 
becomes part of the command. This does not work in jLPEX - if I prompt the 
SBMJOB command, which has *NO as default for LOGCLPGM, I may want to 
specify this value, even though it is the default on my system, because it 
might not be the default on another system where our software is installed. 
However, typing in the value in the prompt does not add it to the command 
string at the bottom. It DOES work if I type it into the source text, but I 
believe I should be able to do this while prompting.

5. The statement below is a valid CL statement. Prompting in SEU handles it 
properly. The jLPEX syntax checker passes it. But the prompter reports an 
error, that COND is an invalid keyword.

ELSE IF COND(%BIN(&PERIOD 1 2) = 2) THEN(DO)

BTW, I am using WDSC for iSeries 5.1.2

5. Another error showed up, but with automatic formatting, not the prompter 
per se:

This source, which is valid

dspobjd qsys/*all *lib +
        output(*outfile) +
        outfile(qtemp/qadspobj)

got changed to

dspobjd    qsys /* all *lib output(*outfile) outfile (qtemp/qadspobj) 
*/

Note that the "/*" was interpreted as the start of a comment, and the end 
comment "*/" was added. However, this is incorrect.

Turns out it is related to prompting - if I prompt the first item, it has 
already changed the statement as indicated above.
================================================