Re: Baseline article: Is There Really an IT Labor Shortage?

[Trevor Perry <trevor@xxxxxxxxxx>]

Steve,

My point was, that the article was interesting.

I certainly don't support lies that are spread - like a "job shortage" - and
I certainly don't support the excuse that jobs need to be exported because
of a so-called job shortage.

As for whether outsourcing is a valid business approach - that is a
different discussion. Using a lie to support outsourcing is not right, IMO.

- Trevor



On 3/14/08 2:21 PM, "SJL" <sjl_abc@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

> What is your point, Trevor?
>
> It seems that we have always been on opposite sides of this issue, and this
> article supports what I have been saying for years...
>
> The claims of technical worker shortages, along with the absurd claim by
> Bill Gates that for each H-1B worker hired that another 3 or 4 American
> workers get hired (janitors, maybe?) are simply ploys by industry to justify
> their desire to replace higher-paid older workers with younger cheaper ones.
>
> (...and that claim made by Billy-Boy is based on "research" done by NFAP, a
> one-man 501-c foundation run by Stuart Anderson, who is a known shill for
> the ITAA and the high-tech lobby)
>
> I'd have much more respect for these companies if they would simply be
> honest about what they are doing:
> "Sorry, Mr. American worker, but you have worked here for 10 years and we
> are paying you too much.  If you are willing to work for a lower salary,
> we'll keep you employed, otherwise we're going to replace you with a cheaper
> worker on an H-1B visa."
>
> You should also read some of the other papers written by Vivek Wadhwa...
>
> - sjl